Some Floridians who claimed unemployment receiving bills for ‘overpayment’

ORLANDO, FLA. — After 18 months of people reporting problems receiving payments from the state’s unemployment system, now many are receiving bills; the Department of Economic Opportunity (DEO) says those claimants were overpaid.

9 Investigates learned this is tied to the very beginning of the pandemic. From mid-March to May 2020, the DEO was automatically requesting payments for people. If people haven’t certified those weeks of payments themselves, the state is trying to collect.

READ: Orange County firefighters push back on vaccine requirements

Josh Watwood is back to managing a sporting goods store in Orlando after being forced to close in the spring of 2020.

“All I drew [for unemployment] was about six weeks,” Watwood said.

Mark Santiago is also back to work a few blocks away at Johnny’s Filling Station.

WATCH: ‘It’s heartbreaking’: Orlando doctor receives threatening mail for stance on masks, COVID-19 vaccine

“I figured once we reopened, that was it,” Santiago said.

Neither of them have thought about Florida’s unemployment system since they stopped collecting benefits more than a year ago, until they received bills from the DEO.

“Initially, I honestly thought it was a scam,” Santiago said.

READ: Fight to help those unemployed by pandemic continues after federal assistance expires

They’re among those dealing with the latest round of overpayment notices from DEO. Santiago’s shows he owes more than $800; Watwood $1,100; and another woman who reached out to us showed a balance of more than $1,600.

“Navigating this has been one of the newest crises of the unemployment system,” state Rep. Anna Eskamani said.

READ: How people with long-term COVID-19 effects can take advantage of federal disability protections

Eskamani says the issue is adding to the hundreds of unemployment-related calls her office is still working to resolve. The DEO told 9 Investigates it stems from the beginning of the pandemic, when between mid-March and May of 2020 weeks of payments were “automatically requested by the Connect system.” The state has created a way for people to go in and request those weeks be certified, putting the burden on the claimants to fix a mistake they didn’t make.

“It’s not their fault, so that’s been part of the challenge,” Eskamani said.

READ: DeSantis announces bill to eliminate FSA testing

Though a DEO representative says notices were sent out to individuals warning them of this problem before the bills were sent, these men say they had no idea. They also say trying to log onto the Connect system or through to a real person for help hasn’t worked.

“It’s just been incredibly frustrating,” Watwood said. “We’ve had all this time to get this worked out, and nothing’s gotten smoother. We hope to get some answers on this.”

READ: Boys caught planning ‘next Parkland massacre’ at Florida middle school, sheriff says

A DEO spokesperson told 9 Investigates that the department sent out multiple notices to claimants earlier this year, including these individuals, using the preferred communication method indicated on the reemployment assistance account.

If the claimants are unable to access the system, it may be due to them needing to set up multifactor authentication, which the department recently implemented and has included in numerous weekly reemployment assistance updates. This guide will be helpful for individuals that need to complete this process.

Although the system has automatically processed re-employment assistance benefits, claimants will now need to recertify these weeks in the system. These certification questions are the same questions claimants answer when they request benefit payments in Connect for each week they remain unemployed.

The DEO has a helpful guide on this, which can be found here.

>>> STREAM CHANNEL 9 EYEWITNESS NEWS LIVE <<<

Click here to download the free WFTV news and weather apps, click here to download the WFTV Now app for your smart TV and click here to stream Channel 9 Eyewitness News live.